Despite what the name suggests, a sterile cockpit is not an excessively clean area of an airplane. Rather it is a distraction-free cockpit–a time when the captain and crew engage only in flight-related conversation.
“The Sterile Cockpit Rule is an FAA regulation requiring pilots to refrain from non-essential activities during critical phases of flight, normally below 10,000 feet. The FAA imposed the rule in 1981 after reviewing a series of accidents that were caused by flight crews who were distracted from their flying duties by engaging in non-essential conversations and activities during critical parts of the flight. One such notable accident was Eastern Air Lines Flight 212, which crashed just short of the runway at Charlotte/Douglas International Airport in 1974 while conducting an instrument approach in dense fog. The National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) concluded that a probable cause of the accident was distraction due to idle chatter among the flight crew during the approach phase of the flight.” Wikipedia.
The Sterile cockpit philosophy has been applied to conversation in the operating room by several specialties. David J. Rosinski, MPS, LCP writes in J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg about the importance of protocol-driven communication between cardiothoracic surgeons and perfusionists noting that eliminating idle chatter improves safety.
Anesthetists, like pilots, are the busiest and need the most focus during take-off (induction) and landing (emergence). Unfortunately, those are times when the room is full of commotion and idle chatter. Gillian Campbell writing in Anaesthesia reported a study where video surveillance was assessed for distractions during critical times and found that distractions during emergence were common.
The following statement comes from the Oregon Patient Safety Commission; “While the sterile cockpit concept is associated with specific times in the flight process, in healthcare the concept is not only applied to specific times in a process (e.g., patient emergence from anesthesia), but also to specific activities (e.g., critical events in cardiovascular surgery) and specific places (e.g., a “no interruption” zone during medication preparation in an intensive care unit). According to Wadhera et al. (2010), “…effective communication can be structured around critical events rather than defined intervals analogous to the sterile cockpit, with reduction in communication breakdowns.”
As Health care professionals and anesthesia providers, we have an obligation to patient safety. There is a clear need for us to take the lead in eliminating distractions in the operating room during critical times related to anesthesia.
What are your thoughts and experiences?
I agree. Emergence is a particularly difficult time. Scrub techs are gathering instruments and surgeons and nurses are talking about anything but patient related issues. Residents and medical students carry on conversation and waking the patient seems to be the least important activity in the room. We need a little respect.
Have you noticed how many times in the OR the boom box or stereo speakers are located in the area closer to the patients head rather than near the feet? When asked for input when redesiging OR’s, I’ve requested that the stereo speakers be located in the celing at the opposite end of the OR from the anesthesia machine. Then I was told “we can’t do that because it would interfere with the circulator being able to hear the surgeon”! It frequently seems OK if anesthesia can’t hear the surgeon talking, or our anesthesia machines or alarms, but God forbid if the circulator can’t hear anything. This has always been a pet peeve of mine. We need to hear the surgeons instructions, anesthesia monitors and ventilators so we can quickly know if things are starting to change. In some OR’s we can’t hear ANYTHING but loud music (often at the surgeons insistence). I enjoy music as much as the next guy, but “volume abuse” creates a dangerous & distracting environment and it shouldn’t be allowed IMHO. And yes, during inductions and “wake ups” our patients deserve EVERYONE’S respectful attention.
I provide anesthesia services in a spine surgeons office where he will not allow ANY form of music. At first I thought that was a little extreme but I’ve found it contributes to overall patient safety and helps everyone to focus on their jobs.
Know of any jobs in the Southwest? I’m ready to move West to warmer weather! IL has been an icebox here the past few weeks.
Airway
Please call 309-454-4617